By Greg Hagenbuch
(An excerpt of this article was published in the last issue of the “The Word” titled incorrectly, however)
Does neutrality claim to simply hold no position? Claims of objectivity, neutrality, and omnipresence flourish in the positivist “culture” of the “West.” As I have seen during my time at college, the academy – yes, specifically Earlham College – has in no way transcended the proclivity to worship such flawed positivist concepts. Although it is high time we interrogate all claims of truth circulating in “academic” discussions – for example, former President Bennett’s claims of “legitimate” protest[1] – I would like to call into question the concepts of neutrality and consensus preventing the BDS Earlham movement from reaching success.
Does neutrality claim to simply hold no position? The concept seems to describe two different meanings in Earlham politics: the idea of a neutral topic, decision, idea, or truth, and the idea of a neutral platform or setting in which to speak. In Earlham’s unending aim to reach consensus, the idea that a neutral space is needed to reach consensus runs alive in the debate over BDS. Because of a lack of opposition present at the various information sessions on BDS throughout this semester, I will not argue against the need for a BDS discussion to be hosted by the “neutral” ESG. However, because the issue of BDS itself was not deemed “neutral,” it could not be the topic of discussion. We are thus being provided will the platforms “Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: Past and Present” and “Israel/Palestine: How do we engage on our campus?” The two senses of neutrality are being run together: the idea that in order to have a neutral space of discussion (which I do not celebrate as ever fully present), the topic of discussion itself must be “neutral.” This conflation can be seen in tweets by Eli Richman, Earlham’s representative at large: “My view: Why prop up failed #BDS policy? Let’s do a forum for Israel/Palestine discussion without incorporating this divisive policy” (@Eli_at_large tweet 10/21/2013) and “How would folks feel about a neutral space to discuss Israel/palestine more generally, not necessarily in the context of #BDS?” (@Eli_at_large tweet 10/22/2013). The topic of Israel/Palestine is no more neutral than the topic of BDS. This new topic is a deflection from the goals of BDS. BDS Earlham recognizes the power discrepancy between Israel and Palestine, recognizes the role that certain corporations have in occupation and seeks to strip Earlham’s investment in these corporations. BDS Earlham does not claim that it will resolve the conflict. The alternative topic for the forums indicates that mutualistic dialogue between various campus groups will provide us with the best answer on how to achieve peace for Israel and Palestine. This mimics the historic, unending call for Israel and Palestine to just “talk it out.” I need not cite how far this has gotten the two parties in resolving the conflict. The stance has been taken that dialogue surrounding Israel/Palestine is a more appropriate topic of discussion. Thus, the call for a forum explicitly on the topic of BDS has been disregarded. Thus, the topic of discussion is not (and will never be) neutral.
Continue reading →